THE VALUE IS IN THE DETAILS
Build a smarter shortlist.
Find the performance your team needs, at a salary that fits.
AI interprets your brief and explains the evidence. Transparent formulas calculate the rankings. You make the decision. Player Directory · Methodology & Limitations
ASK SMARTGM AI
Describe what your front office needs.
TEAM INTELLIGENCE
Investigate your team's needs.
Uses the team selected in your search filters. Fetch a dated MLB 40-man roster, then compare available historical performance.
Talk to your front office
Follow up on the current team, budget and shortlist. Changes are proposed for review. Context stays in this tab and resets on refresh.
Your message and current filters are sent to Cloudflare Workers AI. Roster checks contact MLB. No transactions, offers, or roster changes are made.
Loading MLB player intelligence…
03 / COMPARE FINALISTS
Side-by-side comparison
Next: write the front-office report →04 / FRONT-OFFICE REPORT
Make the case for your shortlist.
Choose the report scope below. Only those players and the current search criteria are sent to the server-side AI service. AI selects relevant evidence; report facts are rendered from the validated records. Verify source data and acquisition terms before acting.
Player Directory · eligibility & profiles
PLAYER DIRECTORY
Explore the player pool
Data & Advanced Settings Real MLB pool
Import a dataset
Upload JSON containing MLB player IDs, statistics, salaries, and dated sources. Validation checks format and consistency; it does not audit source claims.
Import MLB season statistics
Pull identities and basic stats directly from MLB. Add sourced salary and WAR data to the exported file before ranking.
Imports replace the active dataset only after review. Player records are sent to Cloudflare Workers AI for card explanations, comparisons, or reports. Export your dataset before closing or refreshing.
Methodology & Limitations Inside the Moneyball Value Score
Prior-season context: Profiles, AI player explanations, and front-office reports can use verified 2024–2025 records for matching players in the 2026 pool. Scores, salary filters, and roster assessments still use the active season only. Prior seasons are kept separate, with no averaged rates, added WAR, or historical salary ratios. Missing seasons are not zero performance; workload and changes in role matter.
Priority first. Cost in context.
Specialist score = 50% priority + 20% WAR + 30% salary efficiency. Overall value = 65% WAR + 35% salary efficiency. Each component is normalized to 0–1 and the result is shown out of 100.
Efficiency = WAR per $1M ÷ 2. WAR = WAR ÷ 5 for hitters and starters, or WAR ÷ 2 for relievers. All normalized components are capped at 0 and 1.
Playing time & tie-breaks
By default, hitters need 200 PA, starters 50 IP, and relievers 20 IP. Unknown workloads are excluded. A visible override allows limited or unknown samples. Workload evidence is high at 500 PA / 150 SP IP / 50 RP IP, medium at the default minimums, and low below them. These are heuristics, not confidence intervals.
Exact score ties use the raw priority statistic (ERA+ for pitching, then K% and lower BB%), then lower salary, then name and record ID. Capped components remain capped.
Fixed illustrative benchmarks
Priority ranges: wRC+ 70–160; OBP .280–.400; SLG .330–.570; bWAR defensive runs above average −15–20 (not DRS). Pitching blends 50% ERA+ (70–160), 25% strikeout rate (15–35%), and 25% inverse walk rate (4–12%).
For a range [low, high], normalization is (value − low) ÷ (high − low). Pitching walks use 1 minus that result.
What the score cannot tell you
These are heuristic weights, not calibrated MLB valuations or percentiles. WAR already includes parts of offense and defense, so specialist weights deliberately emphasize them again. Compare within the selected position and priority.
Cheap controlled salaries can dominate efficiency. Ratio metrics are descriptive—not market value. Budget applies to the selected salary basis; AAV, annual salary and asking estimates are not equivalent. Trade assets, taxes, and benefits are excluded. Roster review uses dated 40-man membership and available historical performance; no automatic payroll analysis is performed.